
OJEU tender evaluation criteria are the published rules a buyer uses to assess bids and identify the winning offer in a procurement advertised under the former EU notice system. They typically combine price and quality, with weightings and scoring guidance. Today, the right rules depend on the jurisdiction, procurement regime and when the competition began.
This guide follows a clearly hypothetical buyer preparing a service tender. The example illustrates decisions and checks, not an actual procurement or its results. It is practical guidance rather than legal advice: check the applicable legislation and your organisation’s procedures before publishing.
What Does OJEU Mean for a Tender Today?

OJEU stands for the Official Journal of the European Union. Buyers and suppliers still use “OJEU tender” as shorthand for competitions once advertised there under applicable EU procurement rules. EU public procurement notices are now published through the Tenders Electronic Daily service, commonly known as TED.
For UK buyers, the expression can be misleading if it suggests that every current public tender follows the same process as an older OJEU competition. The Procurement Act 2023 regime commenced on 24 February 2025 for procurements it covers. Earlier procurements can remain subject to the previous rules under transitional arrangements. Scotland has its own procurement legislation, and the applicable position depends on the buyer and contract.
Start with the procurement’s start date, contracting authority, jurisdiction and subject matter. Consult the UK Government’s Procurement Act guidance and take advice where the position is uncertain. For an EU procurement, check the applicable national law and the EU Public Procurement Directive, including its provisions on award criteria.
The shared practical principle is straightforward: tell suppliers how their bids will be assessed, apply the published method consistently and keep a record that explains the decision. The precise legal requirements, terminology and permitted procedure still need checking for the particular competition.
The Hypothetical Service Tender
Imagine a public-sector buyer needs a supplier to provide a managed helpdesk service. The buyer wants dependable support, a workable transition from the existing arrangement and a price it can afford. It also needs a defensible way to compare offers without giving assessors room to favour an attractive but irrelevant feature.
Before issuing the invitation, the procurement lead brings together the service owner, a finance representative and people who will evaluate responses. They agree the scope, contract period, expected service volumes and essential service levels. These details are hypothetical and would need to be specified in a real tender; they do not represent a supplier’s performance or a completed evaluation.
The team separates three questions that are often muddled:
- Can the supplier participate? Apply the relevant selection, exclusion or participation requirements under the applicable regime.
- Does the offer meet an essential requirement? Identify any genuine pass-or-fail requirements and explain the consequence of a failure.
- Which compliant offer provides the best outcome under the published method? Score the award criteria using the disclosed weightings and approach.
Different regimes use different terminology and rules. The team checks those rules before deciding how to structure each stage. It does not assume that a supplier’s general credentials can automatically be scored as an award criterion, or that a mandatory requirement can be introduced after bids arrive.
How Should OJEU Tender Evaluation Criteria Be Set?
In the scenario, the buyer works backwards from the contract outcome. A useful criterion should relate to what is being bought, distinguish between realistic approaches and give suppliers enough information to prepare a targeted response. It should also be possible to assess against evidence rather than personal preference.
The illustrative allocation below totals 100%. It is not a recommended universal weighting: a buyer should choose and justify its own proportions before publication, taking account of the applicable rules and the risks of the contract.
| Illustrative award criterion | Weight | What the buyer asks suppliers to explain | Evidence assessors could review |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price | 35% | Total cost on the prescribed pricing basis | Completed pricing schedule and stated assumptions |
| Service delivery | 30% | How the proposed service will meet support requirements | Staffing approach, escalation process and service plan |
| Transition | 20% | How the supplier will establish the service and manage handover risks | Implementation plan, milestones and dependencies |
| Reporting and improvement | 15% | How performance will be reported and improvement opportunities identified | Sample reporting approach and review process |
The buyer would publish the criteria, relevant sub-criteria and weightings, together with the scoring method and any other information required by the applicable regime. If transition has several scored elements, for example, suppliers should understand their relative importance rather than discover them after submission.
Notice what the table does not say: “supplier quality” or “best overall impression”. Those labels leave too much to interpretation. Instead, each criterion points to an aspect of the proposed service and a response the evaluators can examine. For more help developing the structure, see our step-by-step guide to tender evaluation criteria.

What Should the Invitation Tell Suppliers?
The evaluation plan should not live only in an internal spreadsheet. Suppliers need a clear invitation that explains what to submit and how the buyer will assess it. In the hypothetical helpdesk tender, each scored question would connect to a published criterion and give suppliers a reasonable opportunity to present relevant evidence.
For service delivery, the invitation might ask suppliers to describe their proposed support model, escalation routes and arrangements for maintaining service during staff absence. The question should also say how much space or what response format is permitted, whether attachments will be considered and how the response relates to the published scoring guidance.
The buyer should explain the pricing basis just as carefully. A pricing schedule might require suppliers to enter charges against a common set of assumed service volumes. It should say which costs are included, how optional items will be treated and whether taxes are included or excluded. Comparable inputs make a meaningful price comparison more likely.
Before release, a reviewer who has not written the questions can look for ambiguity. If “rapid escalation” appears in the specification, does it have a defined meaning? If a response template asks for a transition plan, does it identify the expected start point and dependencies? A red-team-style review can expose gaps while the buyer still has time to correct them for everyone.
TenderLock can help turn a plain-English brief into structured requirements and weighted criteria, then support a Red Team review for ambiguity. If you are preparing a competition, you can start your first live tender free; no card is required.
How Can Assessors Score Quality Consistently?
The hypothetical team agrees a scoring scale before bids are opened. A scale is useful only if the descriptions tell assessors what the differences mean. A high score should reflect a well-evidenced response against the question, not simply a polished writing style.
| Illustrative score | Example interpretation | What an assessor records |
|---|---|---|
| 0 | No relevant response or evidence provided | The missing response or evidence |
| 1 | Major gaps; the approach is poorly explained | The material gaps against the question |
| 2 | Partially addresses the requirement but has significant weaknesses | Relevant evidence and unresolved weaknesses |
| 3 | Addresses the requirement with an adequate, supported approach | The evidence supporting that judgement |
| 4 | Strong, detailed approach with relevant supporting evidence | The features and evidence that justify the higher score |
This is an illustrative scale, not a prescribed legal standard. A real invitation should include the scale and descriptors appropriate to the procurement, including how any minimum quality threshold operates. The team should also make clear whether a score of zero has a separate consequence under the published rules.
Assessors can first read and score independently, citing the relevant response section for each judgement. They then meet to moderate differences. Moderation is not an exercise in averaging numbers automatically: the panel discusses the evidence, checks the published descriptors and agrees a reasoned score. If agreement is not possible, the buyer follows its documented escalation process.
For example, a transition response might contain a timetable but leave responsibility for data migration unclear. An assessor should note both the timetable and the gap, then explain why the response fits the chosen descriptor. The note should identify what was submitted, not speculate about what the supplier might have meant.

How Does the Price Calculation Work?
The price method must be designed and disclosed before bids are evaluated. One illustrative approach awards the full available price points to the lowest eligible evaluated price and proportionately fewer points to higher prices:
Price points = lowest eligible evaluated price ÷ supplier’s evaluated price × available price points.
If price carries 35 points, those are the available price points in this example. The buyer would apply the formula to each eligible evaluated price, using the same pricing basis and rounding rules. No supplier prices or results are assumed here.
This formula is not suitable for every procurement. It may produce outcomes the buyer did not intend if the pricing model contains unusual assumptions, variable volumes or items that are not evaluated consistently. Before publication, test the proposed formula against several fictional price patterns, including close prices and widely separated prices. Check whether the resulting spread reflects the importance the buyer intends to give price.
The documents should also explain how arithmetic errors, missing prices, alternatives and unusually low offers will be handled, subject to the applicable rules. Do not silently correct one supplier’s assumptions or invent a missing charge. If clarification is permitted, record the question and response and avoid giving one bidder an opportunity to improve its submission unfairly.
What Happens After Bids Close?
In the scenario, the buyer sets a single submission deadline and tells suppliers how to submit. A sealed process keeps responses inaccessible until the deadline under the chosen controls, after which authorised people open and evaluate them. The buyer follows the published instructions and applicable rules for any late or inaccessible submission.
Before scoring, the procurement lead confirms that evaluators understand confidentiality requirements and declare relevant conflicts of interest. The team applies the published participation and mandatory checks in the stated order, then evaluates eligible responses against the award criteria. If a conflict arises, the buyer records how it was managed rather than leaving the issue to an informal conversation.
Supplier checks can inform the appropriate stage of the process, but they should not become undisclosed award criteria. Companies House information can help establish basic company details, while credit information may be relevant to a proportionate financial assessment. The buyer should check the source, date and relevance of each item and give suppliers any procedural opportunity required by the applicable rules.
For a practical starting point, use the UK supplier vetting checklist. It should sit alongside, not replace, the procurement-specific rules and published requirements.

Where Does AI Help Without Making the Decision?
AI can support the administrative work around OJEU tender evaluation criteria, but it should not displace the people accountable for the award. In the hypothetical tender, a tool could organise the requirements, flag an unanswered question or point an evaluator towards a relevant passage in a response. Each suggestion still needs checking against the submitted evidence and the published method.
TenderLock supports requirement-by-requirement response checks and evidence-locked evaluation, with named people making final decisions. Its recorded calls and AI summaries can also help teams retain context, provided participants use them in line with applicable privacy and recording requirements. A summary is an aid to review, not a substitute for checking the underlying record when a point matters.
Keep the distinction clear in the evaluation notes: an AI-generated observation may prompt a human to investigate, but the assessor records the evidence and reasoning behind the score. Do not treat an AI confidence statement as proof, import information outside the permitted evidence base, or allow the tool to apply a criterion that suppliers were not told about.
The audit trail should show the published documents, access and opening records, individual assessments where retained, moderation notes, clarifications, the final decision and required communications. Retention and disclosure obligations depend on the applicable regime and the buyer’s policies. Good records make it easier to explain a decision; they do not cure an unfair or undisclosed evaluation method.

Watch: Understanding Tender Evaluation
For a visual introduction, search for a discussion of weighted criteria and moderation. Check the presenter’s jurisdiction and publication date before relying on any legal explanation.
Frequently Asked Questions
Are OJEU notices still relevant to UK buyers?
They can be relevant when researching older procurements or considering competitions governed by the previous rules. For a new UK procurement, do not assume that OJEU terminology identifies the applicable regime. Check the buyer’s jurisdiction, the procurement’s start date and the relevant legislation and guidance before choosing a procedure or evaluation method.
Can price be the only award criterion?
That depends on the applicable rules and the nature of the procurement. A price-only method may be inappropriate where meaningful differences in quality, delivery or risk matter to the outcome. Decide the method before publication, check that it is permitted and ensure the specification clearly defines what suppliers must deliver.
Can the buyer change weightings after receiving bids?
Do not change published weightings during evaluation simply because the bids produce an unexpected outcome. The evaluation should follow the disclosed method. If an error or other issue makes the published approach unworkable, pause and obtain procurement or legal advice on the options permitted under the applicable regime rather than making an undocumented adjustment.
Should evaluators consider information outside a bid?
Evaluators should use the information and sources permitted by the tender documents and applicable rules. Personal knowledge or an internet search can introduce inconsistent or undisclosed evidence. Where a clarification or external check is appropriate, follow the stated process, treat suppliers fairly and record the source and its role in the assessment.
Does the highest quality score always win?
No. Where the published method combines quality and price, the outcome depends on the weighted scores and any applicable thresholds or other stated rules. A high quality score alone does not determine the award. Assessors should calculate and check the combined result using the published method, then document the decision and required communications.
Ready to put a clearer process in place? Start a first live tender free with TenderLock and keep the requirements, evidence and decision trail together.



